This has been gone over SOOOO MANY times on SOOO MANY boards for different vehicles ive been on. In fact, BMW-Forums.com E46 board has the same discussion going right now. While the bimmer requires 91 or above, the general consensus is that if youre vehicle is not designed for, or does not require higher octane fuels, putting them in is just like throwing cash in the trash. Do not ask me to get scientific here as I can never remember the whole explanation, but essentially a vehicle designed for higher octane run on lower octane runs the risk of predetonation and other hazards, but a vehicle run on HIGHER octane than its designed for, does not gain an increase in performance (Edmunds editors put 100 octane Shell fuel in the tank of their test Ferrari 3xx car and surprisingly experienced no major increase whatsoever). It has already been stated that the manual for the 04 model is incorrect on recommendation of 91 octane fuel.