Cadillac Owners Forum banner
  • BEWARE OF SCAMMERS. Anyone trying to get your money should be checked out BEFORE you send anything anywhere.

Further discussion and update about the ATS transmission shudder (officially labeled Torque Converter Clutch (TCC) shudder by GM (TSB # 18-NA-355)

18K views 34 replies 14 participants last post by  3Point6  
#1 ·
My car is a 2017 ATS Premium 3.6 with 43K miles. Bought new, built to my order.

The issue about the TCC shudder that many of us have experienced, and apparently carried over to a variety of GM models with the same trans assembly, seems to pretty accurately described in TSB #18-NA-355 (22 pages). I got the TSB number, because the dealer printed it in my service invoice (N/C, since I am under the powertrain warranty). The lead paragraph reads like this:

"Some customers may comment on any of the following conditions: A shake and/or schudder during light throttle acceleration between 25 and 80 mph, steady state driving while while the transmission is not actively shifting gears. A shudder feeling that may be described as driving over rumble strips or rough pavement. Shudder feeling evident in both Drive and M7 (MY 15-16) and L7 (MY17/My18) mode."

Well that pretty much well describes what I have been experiencing up to 43K miles. I don't think the issue started manifesting itself until I started entering the mid/high 20's for mileage. You can google out a copy of this and print it out, but reading through it, GM seems to know quite well there is an issue. The mandated fix is a fluid exchange, under this bulletin, in which the original is exchanged for a new trans fluid made by Mobil 1. I am not going to bore folks here with the details, but the exchange is a fairly involved procedure-it's takes 20 pages to guide the tech.....GM say's that this exchange will clear the TCC problem in 200 miles of driving (needing at least two cold/hot start cycles). The dealer DID NOT tell me about that, but the tech service bulletin makes it clear that the customer should be advised that the problem will not be completely resolved until the car is driven 200 miles following the exchange. So my exchange happened today, so we will see what happens in 200 miles.

But now it gets curiouser...The Cadillac dealer invoice indicates that the tech confirmed TCC in my car per TSB 18-NA-355. But then went on to comment (on the dealer invoice) that " the tech performed a trans exchange as per TSB 8480818 Description not provided"..... TSB 8480818??? What the hell is TSB 8480818? I tried to find it on the net, but no go. Anybody know? how does that differ from 18-NA-355?

Secondly, when the service person came out to find me and tell me what they would be doing to my ATS, they said that the service per above would be provided at N/C because I had the powertrain warranty. But she went on to say that they had a special machine with an addictive that would clean the the transmission assembly internally, but I would have to pay $175.00, if I wanted that version of the service....So this left off where they performed a fluid exchange at N/C under 18-NA-355/8480818. But if I found it did not work, I would the to come back and have it done again using their special machine and additive, in which I would then pay $175.00.....I think I drove away from the Cadillac dealer today with birdies flying around my little head...So I am not exactly sure what happened, but I guess I will see in the next 200 miles. But I find it remarkable that no service or tech person at the dealer advised me that the TSB indicates the owner has to drive the car 200 miles to resolve TCC shudder. So I would really appreciate it if others here can chime in their comments/experiences. I would also really like to know more about this TSB 8480818, which I cannot seem to source, myself. I saw also that there is a class action lawsuit in five states, regarding TCC shudder. But of course, my luck, the Garden State is not included.
 
#2 ·
8480818 is not a TSB, that is the dealer use billing code for warranty reimbursement under TSB 18-NA-355.

Coupled with your dealer wanting to up-sell you on using an additive (commonly known as "magic mouse milk") to "clean your transmission internally" shows that you really want to use a different dealer next time. A properly done fluid exchange is all that is necessary and using any type of internal cleaning solution on a transmission that is not being rebuilt would be a very bad move. I suspect that this special additive is something whose only distinguishing characteristic is it doesn't do any damage as its only useful feature.

I have the 8L90 (big brother to the 8L45) in my Corvette Z06 and it has worked perfectly living behind a 650HP supercharged V8. The only issue it has exhibited was the initial rough 1 to 2 shift after sitting overnight, avoided by manually shifting to second and back to first with the brakes on during the first start of the day. It got the new fluid change last year at my dealer, a painless process from a dealer who doesn't try to play games.

Rodger
 
#3 ·
Yes, it did not make any sense to me why it was suggested I had to pay $175 for a factory-mandated warranty service? If the additive did any good, why would GM not include that in
the TSB instructions? It get's frustrating, you think you found one you can trust but then it still goes south....anything non-warranty, I go to third party.
 
#4 ·
I randomly came across this thread and the info about the TSB was just want I needed. My mothers CTS has this rumble issue and I've been meaning to drop it off at the dealer but was wondering how I would describe the issue but having a tsb number makes that so much easier. We also need the rain sensor replaced again because its leaking down the windshield again. Hopefully its an easy fix and the dealer doesn't try to be shady, plus I need to bug that dealer on the replacement taillight for my 5BW that was probably scuffed in shipping. They ordered it but had no timeframe.
 
#5 ·
Hey all... My sister has a 2017 ATS sedan that was experiencing shudder soon after she bought it. It's certifed pre-owned and I rode in the car while it was happening. She brought it to the dealership and had it fixed under warranty. My 2016 ATS coupe also had the shudder, so I looked at her receipt to see what they had done to fix it. I see they changed the fluid out for the new fluid and replaced both the internal and external transmission harnesses. It's been over a year and no shudder on her car yet.
 
#6 ·
I just had this TSB performed at my local dealer and the good news is it fixed the shudder. The bad news is they told me it isn’t covered under any warranty, not even drivetrain or CPO (the CPO just expired last month grrrr). The car is 2017 and has 42K miles. Why isn’t this covered under drivetrain warranty? I’m out not quite $2K because coincidentally the tech said the temp sensor was faulty and it cost over $1.3K to replace that trans temp sensor and its integral wiring harness. Is this legit not under any warranty?
 
#13 ·
Contact Cadillac division customer service also (NOT the dealership) to open a case. They may work with the dealer to cover part of the cost since your vehicle was only a month out of powertrain warranty AND the 8Lxx shudder is a very well known problem.


Rodger
 
#15 ·
You are welcome! And if you get shuffled into a bureaucratic loop, you can always directly email the CEO at GM world headquarters. She won't answer your email directly but there are some very capable staff assistants who are pretty skilled at separating significant customer service lapses from the mundane unhappy customer and that can prove helpful.

Given the magnitude of complaints with that transmission with its "squashed torque converter", GM has been pretty responsive in making certain that customers get the fluid service. I love the 8L90 in my 2016 Corvette Z06 but it was never allowed to go into the converter clutch eating V4 mode and it has the latest fluid in it. The Corvette was particularly susceptible to shudder with the earlier fluid spec because unlike other GM products, it uses a pair of air to fluid heat exchangers to cool the transmission fluid instead of using an engine coolant to transmission fluid exchanger; the latter helps to heat the transmission fluid during short drives in cold weather operation to reduce the troublesome moisture buildup which causes converter clutch shudder while the Corvette fluid remains extremely cool until it is driven hard.

Rodger
 
#19 ·
Melze,

Even after transmission service, this is a good practice with 8L series transmissions for the first start of the day. A clutch pack actuator used for the 1 to 2 shift has a slow initial fill and doing the 1-2-1 shift with the brake engaged and engine at curb idle allows it to fill during a no stress shift and the rest of the shifts for the day should be fine.

I don't believe GM ever addressed this in software for some unknown reason; when Detroit/Allison was still part of GM, the Allison "world" series 5 and 6 speed transmissions had this issue after revised hardware around 2000 with the initial 3-4 upshift and Allison released revised software that did a actuator partial prefill at engine start.

These GM transmissions are adaptive learning transmissions and once they get past the initial fast learn phase, they stay in slow learn for the life of the transmission in order to adapt to wear of the clutch packs. But if the transmission over time has learned a very bad habit then the dealer can put it back into fast learn mode so that the problem behavior can be resolved. This fast relearn will NOT overcome the slow initial actuator fill but it will allow the transmission to quickly learn to avoid issues with clutch apply/release timing and force which will lead to bad shifts that continue after the initial shift of the day.

Rodger
 
#21 ·
Ron,

I can't remember which year you owned but as I recall you had one of the earlier models with the 6Lxx series transmissions and these aren't known for shudder issues like the 8Lxx with its squashed converter. The 6Lxx series was a very well designed and tested series that was also used by BMW in several of their models. It sounds like the dealer (and maybe Cadillac division) dropped the ball on that one because your car either had an internal transmission defect or an issue with the engine/ECM that created the shudder issue and it should have been quickly resolved.

A good dealer tech makes all of the difference but GM customer service used to be a great backstop for failures at the customer/dealer interface. 20 years ago I ran into an issue with a two month old Chevy Impala that would set a DTC for a wheel speed sensor every time it rained. The dealership replaced the sensor twice and then decided they needed to replace the entire rear wiring harness which would have been major surgery.

I contacted the Chevy zone office and the rep intervened and opened a tech support case. Four hours after I initiated contact, he called back to tell me the problem had been resolved. The dealership personnel were replacing the sensor on the wrong side, the Chevy tech rep told me that they can only do so much in providing clear explanations of the DTC in their service literature and they falsely assumed that the dealership service personnel would know the difference between their right and left hands 🤣

The Chevy zone office extended the bumper to bumper warranty out to 5/100K to make up for the inconvenience which was a nice service recovery and the way GM used to do things. Sorry you had such a bad experience Ron.

Rodger
 
#22 ·
Thanks Rodger, I really liked the ATS and would likely have given Cadillac another chance with the CT4 - 5 but wasn't a fan of the new design. I really didn't agonize too much with my car. The Mercedes dealership gave me a great trade in price and didn't even drive it. Seems vehicles are such a commodity anymore nobody seems interested in anything but the valuation algorithm anymore.
 
#23 ·
Ron,

I hear you on the CT4. I went in to place an order for one and after driving the 2.7 I4 turbo I decided that it was the proper engine for a pickup which was the original intent. I was OK with the overall CT4 design but I hated the way the 2.7 felt so I ended up ordering a 2021 Camaro from the same dealership with the tried and true 335 HP 3.6, it is a very smooth running engine designed for 87 octane and really plays well with the GM/Ford JV 10 speed auto.

I will probably return to the Cadillac fold for my first electric daily driver in a few years depending upon what they produce but I have no desire for a crossover/baby SUV or whatever the current jelly bean shape/style is called by that point :)

Rodger
 
#25 ·
I had the shudder issue and had the fluid flush done under warranty in the beginning of August. Today my check engine light came on and I took it to a nearby Cadillac dealer to have them get the codes (different dealer, I moved). They said the codes were for Transmission Control Module and Transmission Fluid Temperature Sensor. They have me scheduled for a service appointment 7am on January 3rd. They said they couldn't guarantee it would be covered under warranty until they did a diagnosis on that day. Any thoughts or suggestions?
 
#29 ·
Can you reset the code and see if it returns? I had this exact problem and the harness in question was backordered. I reset the code and during the six week wait for the harness it never returned. Seeing as to how often this is coming up on the forums it may be related to the flush and is actually a non issue. By all means get the service done, but for peace of mind until you can do it, see if you can kill the code and see if it returns.
 
#30 ·
As long as the transmission isn't acting noticeably different, it won't be any problem driving it until the dealer can get it in for a checkup/repair.

I suspect the only relevant code is for the temperature sensor. When any transmission trouble code is set, the TCM requests the ECM to turn on the CEL and the generic P0700 will be set in the ECM which is just a placeholder that tells the technician that one or more codes are set in the TCM.

GM automatics of the last few decades have different degrees of protection/limp mode and if the temperature sensor is providing no reading or one that is implausible based upon other conditions then a code is set and the reading is ignored. The transmission fine tunes some shift operations based upon fluid temperature and also protects itself if the temperature begins to rise. So without a valid temperature reading, part of the shift "quality" algorithm is based upon a default normal temperature so it is possible shifts will be a little less smooth-particularly with fluid that is very cold or very warm.

To avoid creating stress on the transmission, avoid full throttle starts and downshifts if possible until it is repaired.

The transmission will go into further protective mode when necessary. Shortly after I bought my 2016 Corvette Z06 I also purchased a Range anti-AFM module to keep the V8 engine from going into V4 mode. There was a random conflict that occurred between the Range module and the activities going on within the car's network during initial startup and on rare occasion that would cause the TCM and ECM to lose communication; the cure was to restart and starting and then plugging the Range module in always avoided the conflict. But if you drove it after the communications loss the vehicle was still operable but you only had reverse and one forward gear available which protected the transmission since its TCM couldn't request a power reduction from the ECM during shifts. It is possible to damage these modern automatics but GM builds a lot of protection into the programming and short of a major parts failure it won't leave the owner stranded on the side of the road.

Rodger
 
#31 ·
My shudder started around 50-60k kms. Had the TSB performed which swapped out the hydroscopic OEM fluid to the new M1 LV ATF HP. It was like a new transmission after and has shifted perfectly since, currently at 110K kms.

I do plan on a dump and fill every 50K kms now with the same fluid, which I hear takes about 6 quarts. Which reminds me... I'm due.

Image