I'm with talismandave on this one, I was sold (the idea of) Cragar S/S's when I was at school (you wouldn't understand just how strange that would've been then & here) BUT now, if not going for that period look, I think I'd go for the Torqthrusts!
They both look good. If you tend to be a purist, stick with the factory wheels. It's still a bada$$ car!
I was at our Tulsa plant last year and saw a service cart with Cragar SS's. I had to do a double-take, I didn't know they came that small. I wanted to take a pic with my Blackberry but it's against company policy.