It's a crapshoot. I'm in a unique parts/service quality judgement position because I recently worked part-time at the service/parts counter at our local Western (Tire &) Auto for 5 years for something to do. Prior to that, on and off between careers since 1954, I've been a parts runner, mechanic, chauffeur, used car flipper, other stuff. I recently sold my lucrative marine engine rebuild and modification business - a good deal since Kent Island is ............... surrounded by water

............ and is home to huge commercial and pleasure boat fleets.
I personally have used a mishmash of "new" and "reman" parts in everything from MG-TD 1.25L 4 cylinder engines to full drag Olds 455s and GM 454s. There are wonderful and
not-so-wonderful reman shops for everything from alternators to water pumps to radiators to entire engines. In or close to "the business" you learn in a hurry.
New Northstar part - Remy alternator. Reman? From any of over 6 local electric shops - NOT from a chain box store; those are rebuilt to a bulk contract price. Matter of fact, you can do a total alternator rebuild right in your own garage or on the kitchen table, using parts from Rock Auto or a local NAPA shop. And you learn a lot in the process.
9 of the 30+workboats in this picture run my engines............ some are out crabbing right now ........
An Olds 455 bored .030 over - workboat workhorse -