I looked at several brands of headlights that ran from $180 to $360 and all of them had about equal positive and negative reviews. I suspect the biggest difference is in the installers.

The only lookout I would offer is some have a gray/silver inside reflector and some are black -- make sure that you are getting the one you want.
Quicker and much less expensive, not to mention way easier, is to buy a good headlight refinish/restoral kit -- one of the multi-step/stage kits, not the wipe-on liquids. One of those and a high speed corded drill and you can have both headlights looking like new in an hour -- with most of that time being taping around the lenses.
I just did it and couldn't be more satisfied.