Cadillac Owners Forum banner
  • BEWARE OF SCAMMERS. Anyone trying to get your money should be checked out BEFORE you send anything anywhere.

dexos 2 in a dexos 1 engine

1 reading
32K views 27 replies 10 participants last post by  cawengr  
#1 ·
i know the dexos 2 will protect more but will be bad for the gas mileage,what else can happen if i put dexos2 instead of the 1?can it actually hurt the engine?
tnx.
 
#2 ·
You'll never see a local driving gas mileage difference - maybe 0.5% to 1% over a 1,000 mile trip. Run whatever engine oil is recommended or available in the viscosity range for your ambient temperature - as shown in the owners manual.

API designations SK, SJ, SL, SM, then the GM licensing specs for DEXOS (which are SM and SN oils) - all good oils, all just fine for any engine.

DEXOS is not an oil refining specification as such - it's a licensing specification from GM so packagers can market their oils as "meeting GM specifications" - which it ALL did before DEXOS was ever "invented". AMSOIL markets some excellent oils that are not DEXOS licensed but beat the requirements in spades. So does Joe Gibbs Racing - JoeGibbsDriven.

http://www.api.org/certification-pr...a/Files/Certification/Engine-Oil-Diesel/Publications/MOM_GUIDE_ENGLISH_2013.pdf
 
#4 ·
Just to add some controversy. I put a catch can on mine 5,000km ago. I would get a couple ounces of sludge and water over 1,000km or so. My first oil change as the new owner I used 10W/30. When I checked the can after the first 1,000km I got 1 drop of water. That's it. I would at the very least have expected more condensate.
 
#5 ·
Dexos 1 and Dexos 1 Generation 2 are the new approved oils for most of our cars...Dexos 2 is for Diesel motors...follow the minimum your owner's manual recommends and adjust for what you feel like using...

unless your engine is different from what we have here in the States...Dexos 1/Dexos 1 Gen 2 are both fine...I like Mobil 1 in the proper weight for my cars...

Good luck with your choice

Bill
 
#9 ·
If you truly are changing your oil every 3000-3500km You are doing it WAY too often. Luckily the only thing you will hurt is your wallet as long as you don't weat out the threads from anything you have to unbolt or unscrew.

The original was 3000 miles.

If your changing at 3000km that is roughly 1800 miles and barely over half way under the OLD suggested mileage. And even the most oil consumption vehicles you would be pressed to be more than a quart low. Newer mileage suggestions are 5000 miles between oil changes. I have been told that the oil change frequencies in our cars are too long if you go by the "oil life" measure and have seen suggestions to change oil when that get to 40%. If your using Mobile 1 or other high quality synthetic oil and a good quality oil filter it is not unreasonable to get up to 10,000 miles on one oil change. Especially if you have a high consuming vehicle and are adding another quart every 1500 miles or so.

Rodney
 
#7 ·
For oil duty you need to read the labels. Look at the MOM site link - many oils are rated for gasoline AND light diesel duty. Just because an engine il is rated for diesel duty does, in no way, make it unsuitable for gasoline engine duty.

Oil viscosity and a catch can have no bearing on how much oil/acid/moisture vapor may be trapped instead of simply burned as the PCV systems were designed to do. You drive in Saudi Arabia, your total condensed moisture (from air drawn in as the engine cools) is very low; you drive in sticky Charleston, SC or Seattle on a cool, humid morning (you cut the air with a knife) you get more internal moisture. PCV systems draw off and burn moisture and acid vapor - catch cans trap some of the oil vapor from a high flow - and perhaps improperly baffled - PCV system. Forced induction, when used, also increases PCV carryover.
 
#8 ·
I appreciate your insiteful reply. I am relaying my experience. My PCV system is stock and nothing else has changed. Your understanding of this system is quite complete. Have you any other ideas what might produce this result?
I will keep tabs on my catch cans contents to see if this is an anomalous result.
 
#11 ·
what gasoline engines spec Dexos 2???...perhpas this specification means something else outside of the States...why would you use Dexos 2 motor oil?...are there any benefits to using this?

I just went from an online GM specification between Dexos 1 and Dexos 2 that stated "2" was for Diesel...good luck with whatever oil you choose.

Bill
 
#12 · (Edited)
mtrh, Surf through the newer model forums and find threads concerning catch cans - by SC2150, Mishimoto, others - particularly on the 3.6DI engines. Lots and lots of discussion and how-to info over the last 4 years - it's all in here somewhere.

I agree that a 3,000 km oil change schedule is WAY too early. Today's oil is marvelous stuff and, given today's gasolines an engine driven under a mix of city, rural, and highway conditions will easily - easily - go 5,000 to 8,000 miles on an oil and filter change.

My 2002 Northstar gets over 6,500 miles to the quart of 5W-30 synthetic, the car is now pretty much a garage queen, and so the oil/filter gets changed at 5,000+ or once a year, whichever occurs first. What drains out is clear, light amber colored and oil condition lab tests from Blackstone reveal that the old oil has at least another 5,000 miles left as-is. Some of the GM OLMs (Oil Life Monitor) are set to 12,500 miles. The description of the early algorithm-driven monitors is way up ^^^ in the [Northstar] Cadillac Technical Archive in the top black bar. Newer OLMs also use an oil turbidity sensor.

These days are gone forever ..............
 

Attachments

#14 · (Edited)
I would never go more than 5,000 miles between oil changes. 3500 is the max for me but I'm old school.

I just did an oil change on my CTS4.

I used 5 quarts of the Castrol and 1 quart of Mobil 1 because it was the cheapest single quart synthetic at Crapmart.

I also threw in a magnetic drain plug. I'll post pics if I find any metal shavings.

Advanced Auto is running a sale right now. 5 quarts of Castrol synthetic and a K&N filter for $22.99 after the mail-in rebate.

Image
 
#15 ·
I go over 10,000 miles on mine. Mobil 1, new filter and new O-ring plus I send a sample off to Blackstone for testing. Monitoring your oil via lab testing allows maximizing your oil change interval with facts, thereby making an informed decision instead of an advertising myth.
 
#18 ·
They break down many of the metals and chemicals in your oil that may give you insight into what is going on internally. My first engine was in great shape 'til I took my stupid pill and blew it up. Oh, by the way, change your O-ring when you change your filter.
 
#21 ·
About $30 with postage now ........... You pull a sample from either the drained oil or the dipstick tube and send it in. Tell them what oil you normally use so they have a baseline to work from.

http://www.blackstone-labs.com/
 

Attachments

#23 ·
No. Dexos is merely a "standard" GM has set up for oil manufacturers. It is nothing special, just a marketing tool as well as an income generator for GM. If you want to do business with GM, then you have to have the Dexos stamp on your oil.

Imagine going to the store to purchase oil. Your car manual says "use only Dexos II oil". What kind of oil are you going to purchase/use? Yes, oil with that Dexos stamp on it.
 
#28 ·
The 2017 Vette owners manual calls for Dexos1 oil except for the dry sump engines where they recommend Mobile 1, the GM4718m is an old spec.
"Selecting the Right Engine Oil Selecting the right engine oil depends on both the proper oil specification and viscosity grade.
See Recommended Fluids and Lubricants 0 316. Specification Ask for and use engine oils that meet the dexos1™ specification.
Engine oils that have been approved by GM as meeting the dexos1 specification are marked with the dexos1 approved logo.
See www.gmdexos.com. GM recommends Mobil 1® engine oils that show the dexos1 approved logo for its dry sump equipped engines."