Cadillac STS Forum - 2005 through 2012 Discussion, Had my trans fluid changed in Past Cadillac Vehicle Discussion; I spent three hours car up in the air as far as the floor jack I have would raise it, ...
- 06-21-13 11:09 PM #1Cadillac Owners Enthusiast
- Automobile(s): 2005 STS N*, 1SF, 144K mi.
- Join Date
- Apr 2011
- Fort Worth
Had my trans fluid changed
I spent three hours car up in the air as far as the floor jack I have would raise it, on stands, trying to get the fill plug off...no success.
The third time the Torx bit flew out of there with a resounding PING, and managed to miss my head, I knew I was bound to damage myself...likely the car, too. Plus, I was using aRube Goldbergesque extension on a 1/4" wrench for leverage, and bent said wrench.
Anyway, I took it to the lube shop down the street, 'cause I've always viewed them as trustworthy, and I've been there a few times for annual state-mandated safety inspections, chatted up the guys who have been there for at least a couple of years, now, and I trust them to swap the fluid, the Dexron VI I provided and the filter I bought a couple of years back.
I have records of where the PO had it changed, at a dealer, @ 50K, but even so, the lube guys said it looked like motor oil when draining.
They also claimed the could get only 6 quarts back in, so even though they said they hooked it up to a machine for exchange, I don't quite buy it. They did say they removed the fill plug, which was remarkably tight, so if nothing else, I'll be able to drain/fill in 30K miles...maybe less.
The converter doesn't drain on this into the pan, does it? Wait...it can't, or you'd have to wait for it to fill when it starts. I have a Cummins ISB motorcoach which have a stuck drainback valve in the converter, and it takes a good 15 seconds for it to fill, if it's been sitting a few days.
I really wish GM, and other automakers, hadn't started doing this...'sealing' transmissions, when they need fluid changes, regardless of what they claim.
Looks like I drain/refill the trans every other oil change. Thankfully oil changes seems to be about every 12K-13K miles.
Depressingly, this work cost my $162, though I quite-literally con't manage it. Next time should be different.
- 06-21-13 11:46 PM #2
Re: Had my trans fluid changed
Drain & Drop/filter change OR exchange machine? Did they do both?
Sorry to hear of the trouble but it's not adding up to me. For that price, I could have had my dealer do the whole job. Is there any more to the story?
- 06-22-13 06:10 AM #3
Re: Had my trans fluid changed
Nah, that's it.
Double what I was originally quoted, which bothers me, but that was a couple of weeks ago. Their claim is the converter drains when the pan is drained, and I know it was in the bay for a couple of hours.
I was likely partially rooked on this, however, I trust no dealers in the D/FW area, at all.
+ Reply to Thread
Gear in this thread - Powered by O'Reilly Auto Parts
- PowerTorque Tools - Pliers
Pliers - 5 Inch; LockMore on PowerTorque Tools - Pliers
- PowerTorque Tools - Flare Nut Wrench Set
Flare Nut Wrench Set - 3 Piece; Metric; Includes: 10mm X 11mm, 12mm X 13mm & 15mm X 17mm
- PowerTorque Tools - Ratchet Handle & Socket Set
Ratchet Handle & Socket Set - 14 Piece; 1/4" Drive Ratchet Handle & Metric Socket Set